Socialism is no laughing matter

David Horowitz discusses Martin Amis' new book, "Koba the Dread: Laughter and the Twenty Million" and laments the "destructive romance of the intellectuals." A must read column. Excerpt:

Deutscher, Lenin, Trotsky and Marx all staked their claims on the belief that socialism would produce abundance and freedom. A terrible history has shown us irrefutably that it doesn’t. Socialism is really a theory of economic theft and what it produces is poverty. Socialist systems are unable to even keep pace with the technological development necessary to sustain a modern economy. Moreover, they are fundamentally incompatible with human liberty.

None of these four revolutionaries still admired by the left had a clue about the critical importance of private property in making political liberty possible. Equally telling, none of them understood the necessity of a capitalist economy to technological progress or to economic well-being. In the last half of the 20th Century, vast masses of humanity -- hundreds of millions in fact -- were lifted out of subsistence poverty in those countries that protected and supported private property and free markets. This liberation of poor people into lives of relative dignity and modest luxury by capitalist economics represents a revolution unprecedented in the 5,000-year history of human societies.

2 Comments
Jason Pontin said:

I have just read Koba the Dread in one evening! It's a very enjoyable, if odd, and stimulating book. One caveat, however: American readers who, a la Horowitz, expect to see Communism denounced for its economic illiberalism will be disappointed. Amis primarily criticizes Communism for its civic and political oppressions. As a good European leftist, unalligned politically except for a loose tendency to vote for Labor, he is set apart from the economic liberalism that constitutes such an important part of American conservatism. On the contrarcy, Amis--in so far as he thinks about these things at all--probably favors a good deal of government management of the economy.

Maia said:

I have one suggestion for you guys, the best way to understand socialism is to actually read lennin's and marx's works. the idea was wonderful and workable. the problem was that it went into hands of several idiots who misunderstood it. and crushed the sistem. reading somebodies book is not the way to understand it, neither right is comparing socialism to capitalism. "liberation of poor people" ? -you are wrong. it is not a right term. liberation of people to defeat the poverty was the main idea. unfortunately the poor were only people who really wanted it and liberated.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Chris published on July 29, 2002 7:27 AM.

Interstate Internet taxes a bad idea was the previous entry in this blog.

Why software is bad and how to make it worse... is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index .

Chris Elsewhere

Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on Find me on

Recent Activity

  • Chris tweeted, "Welcome @leahculver and @mjmalone to Six Apart! http://tinyurl.com/6dsowx" Chris tweeted, “Welcome @leahculver and @mjmalone to Six Apart! http://tinyurl.com/6dsowx” 2008-12-01T21:14:43Z 2008-12-01T21:14:43Z
  • Chris dugg the link Six Apart Welcomes Pownce Chris dugg the link Six Apart Welcomes Pownce 1970-01-01T00:00:00Z 2008-12-01T20:10:49Z
  • Chris tweeted, "@marinesetwas we've brought the TP & Vox platforms together so I appreciate the feedback on what features should follow." Chris tweeted, “@marinesetwas we’ve brought the TP & Vox platforms together so I appreciate the feedback on what features should follow.” 2008-11-24T04:50:28Z 2008-11-24T04:50:28Z
  • Chris tweeted, "@euan thanks! Really appreciate the feedback." Chris tweeted, “@euan thanks! Really appreciate the feedback.” 2008-11-24T04:43:08Z 2008-11-24T04:43:08Z
  • Chris tweeted, "49ers are only 5 straight wins away from an 8-8 season!" Chris tweeted, “49ers are only 5 straight wins away from an 8-8 season!” 2008-11-24T04:41:51Z 2008-11-24T04:41:51Z
  • Chris tweeted, "On bogging & bailouts: http://tinyurl.com/6a5zlv" Chris tweeted, “On bogging & bailouts: http://tinyurl.com/6a5zlv” 2008-11-21T20:56:51Z 2008-11-21T20:56:51Z
  • Chris tweeted, "@nseki, @arvind2111 thanks!" Chris tweeted, “@nseki, @arvind2111 thanks!” 2008-11-21T20:54:29Z 2008-11-21T20:54:29Z
  • Chris tweeted, "@marinesetwas, @sahaskatta thanks! And we'll look into the issues @euan is reporting." Chris tweeted, “@marinesetwas, @sahaskatta thanks! And we’ll look into the issues @euan is reporting.” 2008-11-21T20:53:51Z 2008-11-21T20:53:51Z
  • Chris tweeted, "Only one more year to make any sort of 40 under 40 list. I think my only shot is for worst dressed." Chris tweeted, “Only one more year to make any sort of 40 under 40 list. I think my only shot is for worst dressed.” 2008-11-21T20:21:33Z 2008-11-21T20:21:33Z
  • Chris posted TypePad teamwork! on chris.typepad.com Chris posted TypePad teamwork! on chris.typepad.com 2008-12-01T23:48:25Z 2008-11-21T07:30:51Z

Powered by Movable Type 4.2rc1-en

Powered by TypePad AntiSpam

Chris Alden

Christopher J. Alden is Chairman & CEO of Six Apart Ltd., the world's leading blogging company. Six Apart acquired Rojo Networks, Inc., creator of an innovative RSS feed reading service, where Mr. Alden was co-founder and CEO. Before Rojo, he was CEO of Red Herring Communications, Inc., publisher of Red Herring magazine -- described by the Wall Street Journal as the "bible of Silicon Valley" - which he helped launch out of his house in 1993. Prior to that he founded Computer Guides, a consultancy.
More info...

Photos